Mashatile Scandal: 7 Revealing Truths About His Paris Business Entourage

Published: paris June 2025

In May, Deputy President Mashatile led a high-profile delegation to Paris for the South Africa–France Investment Conference. The message was clear: South Africa is open for business.

But photos and videos soon revealed two unexpected attendees—neither listed among the 80 private sector delegates. These revelations triggered public concern over influence, access, and accountability.

1. Mashatile’s Deputy – The Water‑Tanker Tenderpreneur

Sibuyile Magingxa, a young businessman who recently secured a controversial R263-million water tanker tender from Joburg Water, was visibly present at several official events during Deputy President Paul Mashatile’s visit to Paris. He was even filmed walking just steps behind Mashatile during a high-profile reception at the Hôtel d’Évreux, raising eyebrows across political and public accountability circles.

Magingxa’s presence is particularly contentious because the Joburg Water contract awarded to his company, Nutinox, is currently the subject of an internal investigation amid allegations of procurement irregularities and possible collusion. The timing of his inclusion in the Paris delegation — even though unofficial — has raised serious questions about how access to top officials is granted, and whether this reflects a broader culture of unchecked influence and patronage within government-affiliated events.

Critics argue that allowing individuals under investigation to appear at international business summits — especially those meant to restore investor confidence — undermines the credibility of South Africa’s diplomatic and economic outreach. It also adds fuel to the perception that powerful networks can blur the lines between public service and private enrichment.

2. Mashatile’s Entourage Included a Social‑Media Influencer

Lesedi Phala, a former Miss South Africa contestant and model, appeared alongside Mashatile and Ambassador Mthethwa at embassy events .

Her role triggered questions because she is reportedly the niece of Ambassador Nathi Mthethwa.

3. Mashatile’s Delegation List Lacked Accountability

Neither Magingxa nor Phala featured on the official list released by French hosts.

Yet both attended key receptions—pointing to gaps in vetting and transparency .

4. Mashatile’s Office and DIRCO Passed the Buck

After amaBhungane’s queries, DIRCO claimed to advise on invitations while Mashatile’s team said participation advanced private-sector diplomacy goals.

But each party redirected responsibility, revealing a blurry accountability loop .

5. Mashatile’s Influence? A Tenderpreneur in Luxury Settings

Magingxa’s Instagram shows him walking close to Mashatile at Hôtel d’Évreux, suggesting unofficial proximity to leadership :contentReference[oaicite:13]{index=13}.

This raises concerns about who really shapes inclusion in state delegations.

6. Mashatile’s Embassy Appeared Ill-prepared for Vetting

The Paris embassy claimed they invited any qualifying private entity.

However, “qualifying” criteria remain vague and undocumented—no public call or selection process was visible .

7. Mashatile’s Paris Visit Undermines Anti‑Corruption Goals

Observers say this episode contradicts Mashatile’s transparency rhetoric and South Africa’s anti‑corruption drive.

It spotlights how political proximity—rather than merit—can influence access to high-profile gatherings.

What This Means for Mashatile

This controversy highlights broader systemic issues: weak vetting, unclear delegation protocols, and potential use of influence.

Public trust is at stake. If private individuals can sidestep formal processes, what message does that send about South African governance?

Learn more in our Political Integrity Hub and read official statements from DIRCO and the South African Government Gazette.

Follow further updates via Reuters Africa.