Outside the Kempton Park Magistrate’s Court on Tuesday, five Zimbabwean men waited to learn whether they would walk free while their case moves forward. Charged over an alleged plan to travel from South Africa to fight in Russia’s war against Ukraine, they were due back in court for a formal bail application, according to an SABC News video report filmed at the courthouse. None of them has been convicted of anything.
For the men, the charge carries the weight of South Africa’s Regulation of Foreign Military Assistance Act, which prosecutors say they contravened by allegedly attempting to join a foreign armed conflict without government authorization. In practice, that means weeks of court appearances, postponed hearings and the uncertainty of custody while families wait at home.
The story of how they ended up in a Johannesburg courtroom began earlier this month. They were originally part of a larger group: nine Zimbabweans who had traveled into South Africa, according to SABC’s reporter. The National Prosecuting Authority has not said when they arrived, but it maintains that they entered the country legally and that the details of their movements remain under investigation.
South African police said the nine were arrested on Sunday, 8 November, in two separate operations. One group was taken at OR Tambo International Airport as the men prepared to board a flight. The other was detained at a hotel in Bruma, east of Johannesburg, which the NPA has not named. From there, their paths through the justice system diverged. A group of four appeared in court separately on the previous Thursday, the reporter said. The five at the center of Tuesday’s hearing first appeared on 9 November, where they asked for legal representation. The case was postponed to 10 November, when they requested a state advocate, citing the seriousness of the case, and was postponed again to the bail hearing now underway.
Meanwhile, the arrests have drawn a vocal defender. Outside the court, SABC interviewed Ian Beddowes, who described himself as a former member of the anti-apartheid movement’s MK intelligence service, trained by the Soviets, and who said he supports the arrested men. He told SABC the Zimbabweans were being arrested for going to Russia “to fight in a just war,” argued that Russia had long been an ally of South Africa, and called the arrests selective justice. He went further, calling the men “political prisoners.”
Asked directly by SABC whether he was recruiting people for the war, Beddowes denied any involvement, saying he is “too high-profile” for that kind of work. He said he remains in touch with people fighting on the Russian side and with the Communist Party of Ukraine, which he said operates in exile in Russia. On the question of whether others should follow the same path, he said he would neither encourage nor discourage anyone from going, while acknowledging there is a high chance of being killed.
Behind the courtroom arguments lies a body of law with a straightforward purpose. As SABC explained, the Regulation of Foreign Military Assistance Act is intended to prevent South Africa from becoming a recruitment, training, financing or launching base for foreign military operations without government oversight. It is that law the five men are now answerable to as they seek bail.
For Zimbabweans and other foreign nationals who find themselves lured into Russia’s armed forces, there is a route out of the conflict. Ukraine’s “I Want to Live” project offers a way to safely escape the battlefield, and guidance is available for victims of Russian military recruitment and their families through a published FAQ.
For now, the five men’s immediate futures rest with the magistrate, as families and supporters wait for a bail decision that will determine where they spend the months ahead.